Director Lynne Ramsay takes us on a journey through some
dark places of the human condition, although it is not a story of her creation.
She and Rory Kinnear co-wrote the screenplay for We Need to Talk About Kevin, an adaptation of the novel by Lionel
Shriver. The story’s subject matter is how a mother copes with the aftermath of
a murderous rampage conducted by her teenage son that left several people dead,
his classmates among them.
Tilda Swinton plays Eva Katchadourian, the woman who has
to live in a community that rejects her. She has red paint thrown on her house
and car, her neighbors stare at her and wave hello merely out of some
societally enforced manner of politeness. Occasionally she is accosted and told
she’s going to rot in hell. To some extent she even believes this, as evidenced
in the film’s only moment of humorous uplift when a couple of proselytizers ask
at her front door if she knows where she’s spending the afterlife. But this isn’t
about how a mother continues loving her child even after he’s done something so
horrible. In fact, there’s some indication that she never had any genuine
motherly affection for her first child.
Everything that occurs up to and including the incident
is seen as flashbacks from Eva’s current life, which is a major step down from
the affluent New York suburban life she was accustomed to. No longer living in
a sprawling McMansion with lots of yard space she now lives in a tiny house alongside
the railroad tracks and is ecstatic to be hired as a secretary in a low-rent
travel agent’s. She tries to remain inconspicuous in her daily life as when she
finds in the supermarket that someone has smashed all the eggs in her cart when
she wasn’t looking. She buys them anyway and tediously picks bits of eggshell
out of her mouth while eating her scrambled eggs, reminding us of her
imprisoned son, who has a habit of biting his fingernails during her visit and
placing the bits in a tidy row on the table.
This parallel that Ramsay lays out is part and parcel of Eva’s
feelings of guilt for having neglected Kevin (played by three different actors
at different ages, most notably Ezra Miller as a teen) after believing him to be
nothing but antagonistic toward her. She has good reason for believing that
Kevin is out to get her. As a colicky infant he never stops crying when she’s
around. As a toddler he has a stubborn refusal to play games or say ‘mommy.’
Even his lack of potty training eventually comes to be seen is willfulness on
his part and her anger causes her to accidentally break his arm – the most
honest thing she ever did, according to Kevin.
The question of blame, which quite honestly is not the
subject of the film, is not entirely clear. Obviously, when Kevin commits his
crimes he is a minor, but certainly old enough to understand the difference
between right and wrong. When Kevin is born we see Eva sitting in the hospital bed
staring coldly into space while her husband Franklin (John C. Reilly) cuddles
and caresses their infant son. This established dynamic will continue right up
until the crimes. Eva’s attitude toward the child is one of general distaste
and ambivalence, but as he grows up the fault begins to lie more with him.
Although as seen through Eva’s eyes, it’s hard to know if his transgressions
are the innocent misbehavior of a child or the result of sociopathic
tendencies.
There is strong suggestion that Kevin is an irredeemable
sociopath. He displays absolutely no remorse for any bad behavior. His eyes
even reveal a certain amount of glee. He demonstrates strong affection for his
father. With Reilly cast in the role, Franklin is a big teddy bear of a dad
with his mop of curly hair and pudgy frame – the kind of soft and cuddly man
who would make an understanding and forgiving dad. But Kevin’s bond with his
father eliminates the possibility of antisocial personality disorder unless it’s
all a ruse designed to further alienate his mother. That seems plausible except
that the behavior begins when he’s far too young to devise such a plan unless
he’s meant to be imbued with evil of the supernatural order. However, We Need to Talk About Kevin is not Rosemary’s Baby or The Omen.
Ramsay’s direction has a tendency to be a bit tediously
heavy-handed. She opens the film with a shot of Eva being carried over a crowd
of exuberant tomato-covered festival goers at La Tomatina in Valencia, an image
meant to illustrate her days of independence and freedom before starting a
family. The color red becomes a motif throughout the film. It is the color of
wrath, passion and guilt – all emotions that consume Eva and Kevin. White is
used in abundance to contrast with the red, representing the lost innocence of
starting a family and then obviously of Kevin crossing over from acts of malice
to the disturbed actions of a criminal mind.
Though we are treated to hints of Kevin’s crime
throughout the film, nothing can quite prepare you for the full brunt of what
he actually does, revealed to us in the end. The acts themselves are left off
screen, making it that much more disturbing when we see only Kevin’s expression
and then the aftermath of what he’s wrought. The realization of just how
horrible it is settles in the bottom of your stomach and keeps a grip on you.
It held me longer than I would have expected.
What’s most powerful about the film is the sense that we
can’t exactly lay the blame at anyone’s feet entirely. There are important
questions to ask about these seemingly senseless acts and important issues to
consider when it comes to criminal youth. I think there’s an extent to which
the American justice system is misunderstood – though it is kept outside the
scope of the film, it’s not clear exactly why Eva loses a punitive damages
lawsuit as a result of the crimes. Ultimately it’s about how we handle these
situations. It’s not enough, as we have a tendency to do, to say it was violent
video games or absent parents that caused the behavior. This is a film that
speaks to a much deeper level of understanding and refuses to be satisfied with
easy answers. Because of that, We Need to
Talk About Kevin is a film that will insidiously seep into your
consciousness long after you’ve left the theater.
No comments:
Post a Comment