I reviewed this film sixteen years ago in the Connecticut College Voice. It is far too embarrassing to republish the original so in revisiting the film, here is my new and updated reviews.
For a brief time in the 90s and early 2000s, director
John Dahl was establishing himself (in my estimation, at least) as a maker of
dark and fascinating tales of low moral character or the underbelly of places
we thought we knew. In 1998 he brought us, via a screenplay by David Levien and
Brian Koppelman, to the underground and illegal poker scene of New York City in
Rounders. He showed us a seedy
version of New York that stands outside the realm of most Hollywood movies. And
it’s populated with a cast of characters, most of whom you wouldn’t be too
quick to invite into your home.